Dried Out Heartbreak

Gangamma Sake married her former husband when she was 14: Now a mother of two, she survives with help from the NGO Vicente Ferrer, which provided her with a buffalo – by selling the milk, she earns 150 rupees a day (US$2.30), which she uses to repay the debt her husband left behind (Image © Miguel Candela)

The Indian countryside collects its debts

Text Zigor Aldama
Photos Miguel Candela

Heavy rainfall and hail shortly before the harvesting season this year have worsened an epidemic that has claimed more than 300,000 lives in India since liberalisation of its agriculture: the mass suicide of farmers.

On May 14, 2015, Ramnariam Barma woke up with the firm intention of ending his life. He had long been pondering this decision and the government’s refusal to compensate him for the loss of the harvest was the straw that broke the camel’s back.

“We had been losing money for four years because of the drought, but this winter’s heavy rains and hail have left us with nothing. I had borrowed 140,000 rupees [US$2,200] from the bank and 130,000 more from other loan sharks to pay for seeds and for my oldest daughter’s dowry, and I knew I could not return them.”

So he took a rope, told his wife he was going to the field with the buffaloes and went instead to a high voltage tower near the hectare of land that he owns. He climbed onto the metal skeleton and knotted the rope. But when he put it around his neck, some neighbours saw him. “Think of your six children! What will your wife do without you?” Police also soon arrived and together, they convinced Barma not to hang himself.

Parvati Shulka and Rameshwar Prasad cry inconsolably for a few days after their son’s death; it is still unclear if the family will receive the official compensation for Brijomohan’s death – his autopsy points to cardiac arrest as cause of death, rather than from the direct effects of intentional poisoning. Since the government does not compensate natural deaths, the final decision is pending (Image © Miguel Candela)

But the idea continues circling his mind. Now, he fears the time when moneylenders – who have stepped up their pressure on him to pay, fearing he will soon commit suicide – will visit him at home with more than threatening words.

“Someday they will come to torture me. But I have nothing to pay them, and nobody wants to buy my land because it has proven to be quite barren. The government has promised me 9,000 rupees [US$140] as compensation, but that cannot pay for feeding or schooling my children.”

The youngest of the offspring, only 18 months old, stares at his father while he talks. He is barefoot, dressed only in tattered underwear, and shows a worrying lack of activity for a child of his age. His swollen abdomen certifies severe malnutrition. His mother, Shyambae, holds the baby on her lap and warns Barma: “If you kill yourself, I see no reason to continue living.”

A farmer spreads wheat to dry in the sun in the rural state of Uttar Pradesh: More often than not, the extreme weather damages most of the crops, leaving farmers and families in a desperate situation (Image © Miguel Candela)

In the small Indian village of Tendura, a set of dusty streets and mud houses that are home to some 8,000 people in the northern province of Uttar Pradesh, the drama of this family is not surprising. In fact, in the first five months of this year, as many residents killed themselves. And everyone in the village is convinced that the list will continue to grow because the harvest has been particularly bad, adding to four years in which agricultural production has been hampered by another endemic problem: drought.

“Most of the farmers have contracted debts that they now can’t repay. Many don’t see another way out, and just between March and May this year, 65 people have committed suicide in the Banda district alone,” says Raja Bhaiya, director of Vidya Dham Samiti, an organisation funded by ActionAid that is launching a grain bank, “so that farmers can at least eat”.

Uttar Pradesh is not the only state affected. In fact, suicide has become the deadliest epidemic in India since the country decided to liberalise the agricultural sector in the 1990s. According to official statistics – which numerous NGOs say underscore the magnitude of the problem because they don’t include many cases judged as doubtful – more than 300,000 farmers have taken their lives since 1995.

Although the Indian economy is experiencing a golden age, the contribution from agriculture to the country’s GDP is falling steadily – currently at 13 percent despite providing jobs to 60 percent of the population – and 2015 is becoming by far the worst year in the past two decades. “The number of suicides has doubled in most of the towns in the state. In some, it has have even tripled,” says K.S. Singh Yadar, Superintendent of Health in the city of Lalitpur, Uttar Pradesh. Thus, different specialists forecast that this year will surpass the 20,000 suicide toll.

Hair dye products can easily be found in most corner shops in rural and urban areas of India. Due to its accessibility, low cost (35 rupees) and high toxicity, desperate farmers take their lives by ingesting the product (Image © Miguel Candela)

For now, the only thing the government is doing to stop this crisis is to grant a controversial 700,000-rupee (US$11,000) compensation to the families of farmers who take their own lives. Many consider this comparatively large payout an incentive for suicide, and sometimes it is. Bhagunte Prajapati, a 37-year-old farmer, knows that well. Last March 19, he found his father, Boothe Prajapati, hanged in the family barn. He was 60, and he believed that the economic boost from the compensation after his death was the only way to help his family survive after the loss of almost all their crops.

“He had had two taciturn days, barely speaking. I found him dead when I brought him some food. I understand his desperation, because 28 family members depend on the harvest, and we only managed to save around 300 kilos out of the six or seven tons we used to collect. That’s not even enough for our own consumption,” says his son, the eldest of six siblings and himself father of a further three children, while holding the explicit image a local newspaper used to illustrate the event. “So now we barely have enough to eat, and we will have to ask for another loan to cultivate the land next year. If we don’t get it, I don’t know what we can do.”

The Prajapati family has already begun the complicated procedures to apply for government compensation, but they don’t know if it will be granted. “We are expecting the bank to write off [my father’s debt], but he didn’t tell us how much he had borrowed from local loan sharks, which generally accumulate an interest of 10 percent per week. We will have to negotiate with them when we are given the compensation.”

If they actually get it, that is, because the government does everything possible to prevent suicide cases being certified as such. “We aren’t worried because the autopsy showed that he hanged himself and the press has published his photograph, but other people have taken their lives in vain.”

Varalamma Reddingaru, a mother of two (11 and 13) holds a picture of her deceased husband: By ingesting pesticide, the farmer took his life eight years ago when he could no longer pay his debts accumulated from the cost of his tuberculosis treatment coupled with the failure of his crops (Image © Miguel Candela)

A doctor at the public hospital in Lalitpur, who requested not to be named, acknowledged that is true. “It is difficult to deny the obvious when someone has hanged himself or cut his wrists, but it is easier in cases of poisoning.” And many of the farmers, around 40 percent of those who commit suicide, choose to do so by drinking pesticide or hair dye. Brijmohan Shukla was one of them. On April 10, he decided to drink the chemical-laden hair dye Indians often use to darken their hair. He was only 28 years old.

“Some kids found him lying on the side of the road. He had been vomiting something black, and was already dead,” recalls his mother, Parvati Shukla. “But at the hospital they said he died of natural causes.” The autopsy attributes his death to a cardiac arrest, and that’s why Brijmohan’s parents will not receive any compensation.

“It is true that intentional poisoning can eventually cause death from a heart attack, but it is also true that there are some families trying to pass [off] a natural death as suicide to collect the compensation,” says Singh Yadar. Parvati, however, claims they are not trying to take advantage of the law. “My son was under too much pressure. The bank had begun to send notifications to demand repayment of a loan, and we had arranged his marriage to a girl from a nearby village. But the harvest had been much worse than expected and we have not received any help.”

“A few days earlier he had told me he did not want to live like this, but I thought I had convinced him not to do anything stupid,” she says, unable to hold back her tears. “This is how the land collects our debts here.”

For more stories and photos, check out Asian Geographic Issue 114.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here